Duplicating the hands eliminates much of the luck factor but not
entirely. Sometimes a combination of luck and skill is needed to
obtain the best score. Take a look at this hand.
Scoring: Matchpoints
Hand #37
Dlr
N
Vul
N-S
K95
KQJ2
Q1094
K6
J6
865
8532
10754
Q873
1097
K7
AJ92
A1042
A43
AJ6
Q83
West
North
East
South
1
Pass
3NT
All
Pass
BIDDING: South risked missing a spade contract by his leap to
3NT, but his hand screamed no-trump and he wanted to give away as
little information as possible.
PLAY: West had no attractive opening lead and he finally decided
upon the jack of spades, hoping to find a long suit in his partner's
hand. Assuming the spade queen was in the East hand, declarer
counted eleven tricks but this was matchpoints scoring so overtricks
were vital. He won with the king in dummy and led the queen of
diamonds, East covering with the king. South was now up to twelve
tricks (3 spades, 4 hearts, 4 diamonds, and 1 club) and looked for
another one. He saw if East held the ace of clubs along with
length in spades, he could be squeezed. At trick three he played
the jack and another diamond to get to dummy. Next he led a low
club toward his queen and East was finished when he failed to take his
ace. When declarer ran the remaining hearts and diamonds, East
had to discard from Q87 and A while
declarer held A104 in his hand and the Q in
dummy.
Those declarers who did not receive the spade lead made eleven tricks,
those who did made twelve tricks, and those who did and also saw the
squeeze brought in all thirteen tricks. Skill or luck?